Re: Phil and the Confederate States of America???

[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ International Jack Benny Fan Club ]

Posted ByMike on March 16, 2003 at 20:01:19:

In Reply to: Re: Phil and the Confederate States of America??? posted byDavid M. Lynch on March 08, 2003 at 04:11:31:

Thanks for the reply, David; you're probably right! :)

: : The internet movie database biography of Phil Harris (,%20Phil%20(I) ) says that he "always seemed to imply allegiance to the former 'Confederate States of America.'" Does anyone know anything else about this? I know that most people back then would be considered racist (or sexist, etc.) by today's standards, but what exactly was Phil's deal in this regard? Also, I was surprised that he was born in Indiana -- never would've guessed it!

: : (And who names their child "Wonga"?!)

: My personal belief is that the writer of the IMDB bio was a bit confused, probably due in no small part to Phil's being identified with "That's What I Like About the South!"

: In the early to mid-20th century, there was still a supply (admittedly dwindling) of people who had fought in or otherwise remembered the Civil War. In many people's minds, being from the South -- even in spirit, as I don't believe Indiana was part of the CSA :) --meant you were a "reb." For that matter, two or three generations of Southern-born Americans grew up thinking "damnyankee" was one word.

: But much moreso than Phil being a "reb" was Kenny Delmar's character of Senator Claghorn, from the Allen's Alley segment of the Fred Allen Show. Now there was a true CSA sympathizer (not to mention the vocal role model for Warner Brothers' Foghorn Leghorn character)!

: Complicating the Claghorn/Harris confusion would be (and I'm working from dim memory here, so any help in identifying the show in question would be appreciated, folks!) a parody Jack Benny's show did of Allen's Alley, wherein Philsie took on the Claghorn role.

: So perhaps, for any or all of the reasons above, the IMDB biographer was a tad confused. Besides, I just can't see Phil in one of those rebel caps; it'd muss his hair, dad!

Follow Ups

Post Followup




Optional Link URL:
Link Title:
Optional Image URL:

[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ International Jack Benny Fan Club ]