by Roman » Tue Dec 06, 2005 10:06 am
I think that it will be harder for later generations to remember Johnny in the same way that we can remember Jack. So much of Johnny's material was topical because of the requirements of the daily monologue. Jokes about Gerald Ford or Earl Butz that might have left an a 1975 audience laughing will be meaningless to today's (much less tomorrow's) audiences. This is the same reason that a 1970s ratings giant like All in the Family is so much less popular in syndication today than non-topical character-driven comedies from the same era like The Odd Couple.
Those comedians, like Johnny, Fred Allen, Bob Hope, and Mort Sahl, who relied heavily on topical/political humor, find their popularity slipping as the years go by and today's pointed joke becomes yesterday's HUH(?). But comedians who focused on the perennial human condition, like Jack, Groucho, Jackie Gleason, and Lucy are remembered long after their passing.